Monday, March 31, 2008

Will History Absolve Him?

A few weeks ago, Cuban leader Fidel Castro announced that he was stepping down from the day to day running of Cuba. I had some thoughts on it.

In 1981, I was a sophmore transfer at Eastern Illinois University. I had to take a Political Science class. I was instantly smitten; I eventually realized I loved Political Science so much that I got both my Bachelor's and Master's in it.

The very first paper I ever had to write for that first Political Science class was on Cuba. Specifically, on Cuban economics. I chose the subject because I'd long been interested in Cuba. It formed the backdrop of my early life. A couple of weeks before I was born, a U.S.-supported invasion of Cuban exiles at the Bay of Pigs, a notorious fiasco, occurred. Then, when I was a little over a year old, the Cuban Missle Crisis occurred, in October of 1962. This was, most historians would agree, without a doubt the closest the superpowers, the United States and the Soviet Union, came to an all-out war. Cuba has had, for it's size and population, a disproportionate influence on the history of the last 50 years.

A few months ago, my son and I were talking about politics and history, as we frequently do, and about how there arise people in history that believe that they are absolutely entitled to lead. Those people are, for the most part, bad for their country. Tito of Yugoslavia, a Stalinist dictator, was possibly a rare exception to this; he began to look like an absolute genius as Yugoslavia disintegrated after his death into the first genocide Europe had seen since World War II.

I've often wondered, I told my son, what it would have been like if Hitler had been captured alive and tried for his crimes. In the last few years, I told him, we've actually gotten to see a little of that: the trials of Slobodan Milosevic of Serbia, Saddam Hussein of Iraq and Charles Taylor of Liberia. All three men were (or are, in Taylor's case) like the Nazi war criminals that were tried after World War II: sullen, defiant, telling the court that they had no jurisdiction over them.

My son replied that Castro would never have acted like that. I had to correct him; Castro had already acted like that.

In 1953 Castro led an assault on the Cuban military's barracks at Moncada. This raid was an unmitigated disaster, leading to the capture or death of every single member of Castro's group. Castro himself was captured.

For some reason, the regime decided to try Castro for the plot, rather than summarily execute him, as it had done with many of the other captives. Not surprisingly, Castro was found guilty. As he was an attorney, he was allowed to serve in his own defense. His four hour closing statement, on October 16, 1953, has become perhaps the most famous speech of a man famous for his long-winded speeches. It's come to be know as the "History Will Absolve Me" speech.

When I first got internet access, the very first thing I did was to download this speech. I'd long heard about it, as a student of history. It stands as one of the great pieces of oratory, political theater, and, well, chutzpah in history. Castro knew he was about to be found guilty and sentenced to prison. Yet he stood there for four hours and berated the judges, the judicial system and the political system that was about to find him guilty.

Castro was released in a general amnesty of political prisoners and a few years later, he led a group of a few dozen men in a small ship called the Granma to the shores of Cuba. Within hours, most of them were killed or captured. A handful of men, including Castro, managed to evade capture and made it to the Sierra Mastre mountains.

In the great biography of Castro, the late New York Times correspondent Tad Szulc's Fidel, there is a great account of those couple of days in the sugar cane when the handful of survivors evaded the murderous soldiers of the Batista dictaorship. As they lay in the baking sun, sucking on sugar cane for water and sustenance, Castro had a running monologue the whole time, urging them on, persuading them that the victory of the revolution was just around the corner. And this set the tone for Castro.

In his speeches over Radio Marti from the Sierra Mastre mountains, he kept the dialogue with the Cuban people running. After the revolution, this continued, as he appeared on Cuban radio and television in 5, 6 and eight-hour speeches to the Cuban people.

It is, I think, impossible to understand Castro without knowing something about his right-hand man in the Cuban revolution, Argentinean revolutionary Ernesto "Che" Guevara.

Che met Castro in Mexico City in the 1950's. Che, had been a member of the reformist Arbenz government in Guatemala, This experience was a pivotal one in his life, and is key, I think, to understanding the Cuban Revolution.

Che watched as a small band of right-wing capitalists, backed by a small number of mercenaries-- and with the help of the CIA-- were able to overthrow the much greater number of democrats and socialists in Guatemala through control of the radio and newspapers. Later, after the success of the Cuban revolution, he was Castro's hatchet man. He personally had many people put to death. It's estimated that he had 5,000 people executed in the couple of years after the revolution, some for infractions as small as passing out pamphlets.

The hold Castro took over Cuba, with the help of Che and others, was absolute. With that power he did some good things; the Cuban education and health systems are excellent. My ex-wife, who grew up in Havana, recalled that she got innoculations and doctor visits all the time. Yet, he failed in spectacular ways. In that first paper I wrote, I documented disasterous economic plans that left Cuba time and again failing to get away from the monocrop colonial export model. The Soviet Union procured Cuba's alliance by trading its plentiful petroleum at inflated prices for Cuba's sugar. The Soviet Union heavily subsized Cuba's economy for years.

After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, many expected Castro's regime to follow. Yet, they've limped along. Most of the world, defying the United States' bizarre refusal to end the economic embargo in Cuba, has invested heavily in Cuba as a tourist destination. This has not, however, been enough to save Cuba from poverty. Many women, educated women, have to resort to prostitution to survive.

Yet, in judging Castro's success or failure, one must also look at other Latino countries. Cuba has not suffered the massive killings that Guatemala suffered. The quality of life compares favorably to every other Carribean country, and probably to most poor rural and urban areas of the United States.

One thing that gets little mention is the fact that it was the defeat of the South African army in a proxy war in Namibia, largely by Cuban troops, in the late eighties that began the end of Apartheid in South Africa. Cuba sent doctors and teachers throughout Africa and Latin America. In the vaunted 1983 US invasion of tiny Grenada, most of the Cuban "soldiers" were construction workers there to build an airport so that Grenada could build up a tourist trade. The idea that the runways were to be used to land communist jets to export invasion and revolution into Latin America were figments of the Reagan administration's imagination.

In his classic book, "Political Order in Changing Societies," Samuel Huntington lists a number of strategies a leader of a developing country, or a "Third World" country, as we called them in the old days, can stay in power. It was, I've always thought, the modern version of Macchiavelli's "The Prince." The imperative, in both books, was not change, not improving your country, but staying in power.

Castro has kept Cuba from brutal disaster. He has also kept it from growing up. He's been a genius at keeping power. I sometimes wonder what decisions I would have made were I have been in his shoes. He's often made decisions that to me were bad politically or economically. Then again, I've made decisions that were disasterous for me personally. What the hell do I know.

In the end, the model that may apply is one from Spain, where Castro's father was from: the caudillo-- the Spanish godfather.

The village caudillo had power, but ostensibly used it justly (though this was often a myth). Interestingly, the Spanish dictator Franco and Castro's father were from villages near one another in Spain. The caudillo tradition was well entrenched there.

But Castro has stepped down, nominally, at least, from the day to day power in Cuba. In his place, he's left his brother Raul, absolutely loyal to him, but a mediocrity. And nearly as old as he is.

I have to say that I never expected Castro to step down voluntarily. He clearly thought that he had a mission, a right to be in power. But then again, so does every other person who tries to attain power, whether it be through the ballot or bullet.

To me, it's too early to judge Castro. I definitely have both accolades-- Cuba was not a horrific charnel house like Guatemala, El Salvador or Honduras-- and I have severe criticism. My first wife's father, an artist and dissident, spent years as a political prisoner in Cuba. He was released and made it to the United States, but was and is a broken man. And Castro seems to have a complete inability to understand economics, or at least has a Machiavellian tendency to ignore economics in favor of political considerations.

History is a funny thing. Men and women who are leaders may look good at the time, but look bad in retrospect. And vice versa. It's hard to tell, in the crucible of the times, who is really doing a good or bad job. In the end, time tells. And I believe it will be some time before we can tell whether history absolves Castro.


Jane Rickard said...

Who would of thought we would come to think of Nixon as having a few great liberal ideas. Like the EPA and the war on cancer. Every day as I wrap my favorite pashmina scarf around my neck I am reminded that the political demon of my youth opened the doors of trade and is keeping me warm today.

Natalie said...

A very interesting read

Henry Gomez said...

Dr. Antonio de la Cova has written a the first scholarly look at the events of the Moncada attack. Among the many things he discovered in his research is the fact that Castro never uttered the phrase "History will absolve me" at his trial. None of the contemporary news accounts of the time corroborate him saying that exact phrase. If I remember correctly the phrase was "History will certainly tell it all." He later embellished the speech while he was in jail and published it.

Secondly, I want to remind you that in Cuba in 1953 the death penalty was illegal. The constitution of 1940 banned it. As de la Cova points out, that did not stop military officials from executing many of the Moncada attackers and scattering their bodies to make it look like they died in the fighting. But castro was captured days after the fighting after arranging a surrender. Batista, though he was a dictator, went to great lengths to act as a "President". Castro's once captured alive could not be summarily executed in violation of the Cuban constitution. The general amnesty that the Cuban congress passed and Batista signed is an example of he tried to appear presidential rather than dictatorial. I'm quite sure he regretted that fateful decision.

I disagree with you about the embargo and I think you give too much credit for the "social advances" of the Revolution. Cuba was a very progressive country before castro (as the 1940 constitution I mentioned demonstrates) but it did have it's problems. The regime has effectively re-written history to present pre-castro Cuba as a cartoonish third world country which it was not.

BoonDock said...

Interesting post.. it is dangerous though to just say things like
"One thing that gets little mention is the fact that it was the defeat of the South African army in a proxy war in Namibia, largely by Cuban troops, in the late eighties that began the end of Apartheid in South Africa."
This is a hotly contested view (to say the least).


Erik Donald France said...

Thoroughly enjoyable.

Viva Cuba!

SamuraiFrog said...

Excellent post. Like you say, it will be some time before we can tell the historical view of Cuba. I take the long view of history, with everything as a consequence, intended or no, of everything that happened before it. Batista was a dictator who killed a lot of people; he suspended the Constitution of 1940 before Castro even got close to power. Most of Cuba's post-Spanish-American War history is as a puppet for American trade interests, and I think the ridiculous (and useless) embargo we have against Cuba to this day, which most of the rest of the world ignores and has done nothing to harm Cuba (but much to prop up Castro's dictatorship), is a reaction to the loss of a market.

I do think that there's been too much in the media attempting to absolve Castro of things no one should be absolved of, but I don't think you've done so here. Castro presents a historical problem; he's done great things and he's done awful things. He's a fascinating and polarizing figure.

TTC said...

I don't see any of it. I'm sorry. I cannot see where castro has done anything great except marketing and branding. Goes to show it is not the product itself, but the marketing mind behind it.

As far as health care is concerned, the statement that castro has evolved health care in Cuba is just more parroting the ad campaigns than anything else.

I keep asking for the address to the hospital in Cuba where this great health care is to be had, but not one of those who speaks of great health care can come up with an address for me to send my family to.

do you know why? THERE IS NO GREAT HEALTH CARE IN CUBA! Cockroach and fly infested hospital rooms with non working plumbing, and electrical wires hanging from dilapidated ceilings. Drunk doctors and even doctors and nurses smoking in the operating room. I've seen that with my own two eyes.

I enjoyed parts of the article, but it never swayed too much from anything I can already read in Granma.

Anonymous said...

[b]All of these girls are online now! just click on your favourite to go to their cam![/b]

[url=][img][/img][/url] [url=][img][/img][/url]
[url=][img][/img][/url] [url=][img][/img][/url]
[url=][img][/img][/url] [url=][img][/img][/url]
[url=][img][/img][/url] [url=][img][/img][/url]
[url=][img][/img][/url] [url=][img][/img][/url]

this will keep updating with the latest girls!

Anonymous said...

China and Russia put the blame on some screwed up experiments of US for the earthquake that happened in Haiti.
Chinese and Russian Military scientists, these reports say, are concurring with Canadian researcher, and former Asia-Pacific Bureau Chief of Forbes Magazine, Benjamin Fulford, who in a very disturbing video released from his Japanese offices to the American public, details how the United States attacked China by the firing of a 90 Million Volt Shockwave from the Americans High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program (HAARP) facilities in Alaska
If we can recollect a previous news when US blamed Russia for the earthquake in Georgio. What do you guys think? Is it really possible to create an earthquake by humans?
I came across this [url=]article about Haiti Earthquake[/url] in some blog it seems very interesting, but conspiracy theories have always been there.

Anonymous said...

loved las vegas? manipulate the all unexpected [url=]casino[/url] las vegas at with greater than 75 exhibitionist copious [url=]online casino[/url] games like slots, roulette, baccarat, craps and more and obtain in excessive existent coins with our $400 cost-free bonus.
we from too geezer games then the to pieces online [url=]casino[/url]!

Anonymous said...


I just joined this lovely site. Loads of people have added so many good things here. I would also like to add some thing for this community. I would like to share some [url=]quick weight loss tips[/url]. If you need to know how to lose 10 lbs in a calendar week, you are probably not seeing for a general dieting and work out plan. You can lose weight with a regular diet and work out plan, Still this requires a lot of time doing intense cardio workouts and sticking with a strict diet. Here I will outline the exact steps that I took to lose 10 pounds in just a week.

1. Stay away from all fried nutrients for the week
2. Drink In an 8oz glass of Citrus paradisi with breakfast each day. (this speeds up your metabolism)
3. Take limited portions (stop eating when you are full)
4. Rather than taking 3 big a meals a day, eat 5-6 smaller meals to keep your metabolism up and keep your body burning fat.
5. Do not eat anything after 9pm. When you eat that late your body does not burn off the calories.
6. Get plenty of sleep every night. Not having enough sleep causes been proved to be a major factor to the body putting up excess fat.
7. Apply a body/colon clean for the 7 days. This will get rid of needless fat stored around the tummy area as well as cleanse your body of harmfull pollutants that cause you store fat and feel tired. Flush away excess pounds around the stomach area that otherwise would be hard to lose.
8. I advice you using Acai Berry Diet Pills. This one is proven to work, and you can get a free trial.
9. For those man's/womans who wish to burn fat quickly, avoid alcohol.
10[url=].[/url] A low GI diet is an excellent method of burning fat quickly.


Anonymous said...

According to one of the uploaders the following changes have been made to build 7227

1. Changes in the mechanism for displaying thumbnails in the taskbar.

2. Pop-Up lists for the panel

3. Pop-Up lists for Remote Desktop

4. Applying the settings of the taskbar

5. Multitouch zoom

6. Invert selection

7. You can search for music by artist

8. View the contents of the search results

9. Intelligent indexing after installation

10. Reducing the length of playback sounds system

11. Changes in the panel Devices and Printers

12. Changes in the mechanism of extraction devices

13. Support for FireWire-cameras

14. Reduction in section in system

15. Improved driver support

16. Reducing the paging file

17. Assigning a letter to boot with two OS loaded

18. Naming the section reserved for the system.

There are rumors out there that this build could be fake and that build 7230 will be leaked tomorrow evening.
to know how the new SP looks and to see the screen shots visit [url=]this pageabout windows 7[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi, as you may already found I'm newbie here.
Hope to receive any assistance from you if I will have some quesitons.
Thanks in advance and good luck! :)

Anonymous said...

hi great post, cheat bejeweled on facebook with this cheat check it out

[url=]bejeweled cheat[/url]

Anonymous said...

Witam doszedlem do wniosku ze ta strona jest najlepsza jezeli chodzi o [url=]kredyt studencki[/url].

Anonymous said...

Hi I am new here but I am trying to find [url=]restaurant coupons in tampa[/url] and wondered if anyone has been to Tampa?

I love it there but I get lost easily. I wonder [url=]where can I find restaurant coupons tampa florida[/url] everytime I visit and finally I found a website called that offers
businesses a listing on their site and helps consumers like us [url=]find local restaurant coupons tampa[/url] so maybe someone has heard of it? If you have not
then you got to check it out. [url=]tampa bay coupon book[/url]

Anyway, back to work

Anonymous said...

[COLOR="Red"][B]Click on the pictures to view in full size[/B][/COLOR]

[URL=][IMG] Kaif-314.jpg[/IMG][/URL]

[URL=][IMG] Kaif-309.jpg[/IMG][/URL]

[URL=][IMG] Kaif-306.jpg[/IMG][/URL]


[url=][b]Katrina Kaif Sexy Wallpapers[/b][/url]

Photo gallery at t is dedicated to Katrina Kaif Pictures. Click on the thumbnails for enlarged Katrina Kaif pictures, exclusive photographs and absolute photos. Also validate exposed other Pictures Gallery recompense Squeaky grade and High Decision twin scans, film captures, talkie promos, wallpapers, hollywood & bollywood pictures, photos of actresses and celebrities

Anonymous said...

It's so easy to choose high quality [url=]replica watches[/url] online: [url=]Rolex replica[/url], [url=]Breitling replica[/url], Chanel replica or any other watch from the widest variety of models and brands.

Anonymous said...

Watch Gossip Girl Online For Free - Gossip Girl Streaming Online


Hi [B]Upper East Siders[/B]!
Come And Welcome to my website: [B][URL=""][B]Gossip Girl[/B][/URL][/B]
Whether you’re a Hampton Baby, Central Park [B]Prada[/B] gal, or you even dwell in *[B]gasp[/B]* Brooklyn, [I]this site is for you.[/I]
Why? The answer’s easier than deciding [B]what to wear[/B] tomorrow to school.
[B]Because [/B]my website has [B]all [/B]the latest [B]gossip[/B] about [B]Serena[/B], [B]Blair, Dan [/B]and the other poor little rich kids on the Upper East Side.


Anonymous said...

[url=] Buy reductil online

Anonymous said...

The French gourmet cheese Bleu d'Auvergne has a wonderful aroma, a rich taste; the saltiness increases with the incidence of veining. The overall flavor is piquant but not overly sharp. Bleu d'Auvergne started life as an imitation of Roquefort, using cow's milk in place of sheep's milk. Legend has it that a peasant, around 1845, decided to inject his cheese with a blue mold that he found growing on his left-over bread (the motto being, waste not, want not). And thus, the gourmet cheese Bleu d'Auvergne was born. This French gourmet blue cheese comes from the region of Auvergne and the cheese is made from milk of Salers and Aubrac cows. The rind is very thin and so the cheese is usually wrapped in foil. The cheese is rich and creamy with a pale yellow color and scattered holes and well-defined greenish-blue veining. We cut and wrap this cheese in wedge of 8 ounces and 1 pound.

buy fresh blue cheese

[url=]buy fresh blue cheese[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi..I'm Matthew